Sellers Outnumber Buyers by 500,000: The Silent Collapse in Housing
The U.S. housing market is drowning in a record-breaking $698 billion of homes for sale—up 20.3% from last year and the highest figure we’ve ever seen. While the mainstream press crows about “pent-up demand” and “affordability challenges,” the hard truth is that nearly half of this mountain of listings is going stale as sellers outnumber buyers by nearly half a million.
The data, pulled from Redfin’s latest analysis, reveals an inconvenient reality: the housing market is shifting, and the balance of power is moving back to buyers—at least, those who still have enough cash or credit left to compete in this high-cost environment. Homes are lingering on the market for 40 days on average—five days longer than last year. Worse yet, 44% of listings in April have been sitting around for more than 60 days, a number that hasn’t been this high since the pandemic’s first wave of panic selling.
So why is all this inventory just sitting there? The answer is simple: buyers are backing away from record-high monthly payments and widespread economic instability. Redfin data confirms that there are 490,000 more sellers than buyers in today’s market—a 34% imbalance that no amount of “motivated seller” chatter can paper over.
The old market—where homes flew off the market in 24 days in 2022—was fueled by cheap debt and FOMO. That world is gone. Mortgage rates are stuck above 6.7%, home prices keep inching up, and every would-be buyer is questioning whether these high prices are sustainable. Many aren’t buying at all.
Sellers, for their part, are finally waking up. Many clung to the delusion that their homes would fetch pandemic-era highs, but as listings go stale and buyers vanish, they’re being forced to negotiate. Redfin’s economists now expect home prices to fall another 1% by the end of this year—hardly a dramatic drop, but enough to erode the illusions of sellers who still think they can get top dollar.
Of the nearly $700 billion in total listings, $331 billion—almost half—is tied up in stale inventory. Homes that sit for 60 days or more rarely command peak prices. They become bargaining chips in a buyer’s market—if buyers even show up at all.
The mainstream narrative paints this as a “correction,” but the deeper story is one of systemic rot. Mortgage-rate lock-in, economic fears, and decades of wage stagnation are finally colliding. Homeowners who locked in 3% mortgage rates during the pandemic are now forced to sell because of layoffs, job changes, or divorce. The only thing worse than paying 7% on a new mortgage is watching your overpriced listing gather dust while reality sinks in.
History tells us that when sellers outnumber buyers, prices must come down. We saw it in 2018, and we’re seeing it now. In November 2018, when rates briefly spiked to 4.87%, sellers outnumbered buyers by 9.4%, and price growth collapsed soon after. Today’s imbalance—34% more sellers than buyers—is three times as large.
The takeaways are clear:
✅ Sellers – If you’re sitting on an overpriced listing, stop waiting for some miracle buyer. Price cuts or upgrades are the only way out.
✅ Buyers – For those who can still afford to play in this rigged housing casino, your patience may finally be rewarded. The tide is turning.
But don’t be fooled. Even if prices fall slightly, the real threat is the broader economic rot that’s pushing homeowners to sell in the first place—rising taxes, wage stagnation, and the Federal Reserve’s endless games. The housing market is just another canary in the coal mine of America’s financial decline.
Want to protect your wealth as the housing bubble deflates?
Bill Brocius’ free guide, “7 Steps to Protect Yourself from Bank Failure,” can show you how to safeguard your money when the system fails. Download it now: Download the 7 Steps Guide.
And for a deeper look at how to survive and thrive, grab Bill’s book, End of Banking As You Know It, and join the Inner Circle newsletter: Subscribe Here.
Stay vigilant. The truth is in the numbers, not the headlines.
