separate school and state

The “Public” School Scam: How Government Classrooms Became Indoctrination Camps

EDITOR'S NOTES

Parents are right to be furious about what’s happening in America’s schools, but outrage alone won’t solve the problem. This article makes the case that the real enemy isn’t just “woke” curriculum—it’s government control itself. As long as education is run, funded, and regulated by the state, schools will remain tools of political power rather than centers of learning. The only lasting solution is a complete separation of school and state.

The Woke War in Schools Is a Symptom, Not the Disease

Across the country, parents are waking up to what their children are being taught. Radical gender ideology. Moral relativism. Open hostility to faith, family, and tradition. The anger is justified, but the focus is often misplaced. Too many well-meaning Americans believe the solution is to swap out one set of ideas for another inside the same broken system.

That approach fails because it misunderstands the core problem. Government schools are not neutral institutions. They are political institutions. Whoever controls the state controls the curriculum. When the left wins an election, the schools shift left. When conservatives push back, the fight simply resets for the next cycle. This is not a flaw in the system. This is the system working exactly as designed.

Government Control Guarantees Endless Conflict

As long as schools are funded by tax dollars and overseen by bureaucrats, education will remain a permanent culture war. Parents will always be fighting school boards. Teachers’ unions will always be lobbying for power. Politicians will always be using children as leverage.

When the government runs education, control always follows the money. Standards become mandates. Mandates become enforcement. Enforcement becomes punishment. Families that dissent are labeled extremists, backward, or dangerous. The result is not unity or learning, but resentment and decline.

You cannot have educational peace in a system built on coercion.

The Free Market Solution the Elites Refuse to Acknowledge

There is only one arrangement that ends these conflicts: a genuinely free market in education. When schooling is voluntary, parents—not politicians—decide what their children learn. Schools must earn trust instead of demanding compliance. Bad schools fail. Good schools grow. That is accountability the political class fears.

Ludwig von Mises understood this clearly. In a free society, producers do not dictate outcomes; consumers do. Parents “vote” with their dollars, and entrepreneurs respond by offering schools that reflect real demand. When families are dissatisfied, they leave. No hearings. No lawsuits. No ideological warfare. Just choice.

That kind of system doesn’t produce uniformity. It produces diversity—real diversity, rooted in values, faith, culture, and community.

The “What About the Poor?” Argument Is a Power Grab

Every defense of state schooling eventually leans on the same talking point: poor families. It sounds compassionate, but it is routinely used as a moral shield for centralized control. Mises rejected this argument outright. He warned that when the state takes over education “for the children,” it ultimately takes over society itself.

Private charity, low-cost schools focused on fundamentals, apprenticeships, homeschooling, and community cooperation all existed long before government monopolized education. They can exist again. A child raised free but imperfect is better off than one molded into obedience by the state.

The ruling class prefers credentialed conformity to independent thinking. That is why they insist there is “no alternative” to government schools.

Why Vouchers Are Not Freedom

So-called school choice programs, especially vouchers, are sold as a compromise. They are not. They are a trap. Once government funds education—even indirectly—it claims the right to regulate it. Curriculum standards follow. Compliance rules follow. Speech restrictions follow.

We’ve already seen the end result in higher education: ideological conformity, administrative bloat, and intellectual decay. Vouchers do not shrink the state’s role. They extend it deeper into private life, quietly absorbing independent schools into a government-approved framework.

If the state pays, the state controls. There are no exceptions.

Compulsory Attendance Is an Assault on Parents

Mandatory schooling laws are often defended as protection for children, but in practice they serve another purpose: they allow the government to define what education is and to outlaw alternatives. Homeschooling, religious instruction, neighborhood learning groups—all exist at the pleasure of regulators.

This is a profound violation of parental authority. Parents do not exist to serve the education system. The education system should serve families. Compulsion flips that relationship on its head and normalizes state supremacy over the household.

Education Is More Than a Classroom

Murray Rothbard reminded us of a truth modern society has tried to forget: education is not confined to classrooms, schedules, or standardized tests. Children are learning constantly—through family life, work, play, faith, and observation. In the deepest sense, every person is self-educated.

The state does not create minds. It attempts to shape them. That distinction matters, because shaping is about control, not growth.

The Three R’s—and Nothing More

Reading, writing, and arithmetic are essential. Master them early, and the doors of human knowledge open wide. Everything else modern schools obsess over—social conditioning, political messaging, therapeutic jargon—is unnecessary at best and destructive at worst.

Schools that focus on fundamentals can operate at low cost and high effectiveness. Indoctrination is expensive. Education is not. That alone should tell you where today’s priorities lie.

Homeschooling Terrifies the System for a Reason

Homeschooling works. It produces independent thinkers. It bypasses bureaucracy. It restores authority to parents. That is precisely why regulators view it with suspicion. Every child educated outside the state’s reach represents a crack in the monopoly.

Freedom always looks dangerous to those who depend on control.

The Only Real Solution: Separate School and State

There are no partial fixes. No clever reforms. No safe compromises. As long as the government controls education, schools will be used as tools of power. The culture war will rage on, and children will remain the collateral damage.

Educational freedom requires a clean break. Separate school and state—completely, unapologetically, and permanently.

Join the Fight for Real Freedom

The same elites centralizing education are centralizing money, media, and political power. They thrive on distraction and dependency. If you want clear-eyed analysis, uncensored discussion, and strategies for resisting this system, you need to be connected to people who see the full picture.

👉 Join the DeDollarize News Inner Circle — normally $39.95, now just $19.95 per month

This fight doesn’t end in the classroom.
It starts there.